The 19 Wayfair Hidden Gems Currently In Our Carts, Just In Time For Way Day

Super Sale Alert: Products in this story are marked down even further for Way Day, Wayfair’s biggest sale of the year. Shop our full coverage of the event here — or, dive directly into the deals here.

Wayfair is the endless, questionably organized, and generally delight-inducing hub that hides a million treasures — both small and large — for our dwellings. This legendary online warehouse is packed to the brim with essential home goods, valuable nonessentials, and absolutely nutty decor that would make any shopaholic weak in the knees. Or, you know, log into their Paypal accounts (via auto-filled passwords, of course). And while there is certainly a slew of greatest hits for which the retailer is known — one era-defining home office chair earned an MVP Award from Most Wanted in 2020 — beyond that sea of upholstery lies an unopened treasure chest full of hidden gems that we are officially bringing to the surface. 

Anyone who has ever approached the retailer’s pages with a mission to find a specific piece — or stumbled across something so unnecessarily stylish that they couldn’t believe their eyes — knows a diamond in the Way-rough when they see one. It’s anything so perfectly functional and sharply priced that you find yourself looking around and wondering out loud: “Why don't more people know about this fabulous product?” Or, it’s that cooler-than-it-needs-to-be accent piece that you can’t wait to put out on display and smugly inform visitors that it’s actually from Wayfair. We’ve had our fair share of these too-good-to-be-true moments while cruising around the site — and if you know us, you know that we do not gatekeep when it comes to shopping.

So prepare yourself for popcorn makers, portable kitchen islands, golden table lamp sets, and more Wayfair hidden gems residing in our living spaces and at the top of our wishlists, below.

"I lucked out with the kitchen in our rental — it's huge for the size of our duplex. But despite having two sinks, two pull-out trash cans, and more cabinet space than we could reasonably use, my biggest gripe is that the sinks don't have pull-down faucets. I've been thinking about doing a little switcheroo (what my landlord doesn't know won't hurt him) and I love how many colors this industrial option comes in, starting comfortably under $200." —Marshall Bright, Affiliate Editor

"Everything everyone says about Le Creuset is true. It’s versatile, durable, and literally lasts forever. (There’s a reason it’s on every couple’s wedding registry!). This Dutch oven is perfect for prepping everything from soups to stir-fry. Honestly, it could single-handedly make your holiday meals for the whole family and the neighborhood for the next 50 years (I’m not exaggerating my sister has had hers for over a decade, and it’s still immaculate) while looking gorgeous sitting out on the counter. These pricey pots rarely go on sale, so this is a real find." —Charlotte Lewis, Sexual Wellness Content Producer/Writer

"My girlfriend is an amateur baker, and when we moved in together, I quickly realized we needed an extra storage solution for our small apartment kitchen ASAP. After looking at approximately 1,000 shelves and islands, this prep table stood out as the winner immediately. Not only is the price right (under $200!), but it’s somehow both narrow and long enough for our galley kitchen and adds a touch of French country cottage core to our home. LOVE!" —Charlotte Lewis, Sexual Wellness Content Producer/Writer

"I'm a plant mom. I love the calmness of having a plant around, and I strongly believe you can never have too many. While there are strings of greenery around my apartment, the painting area is a bit lacking. Hence, this leaf painting would fit perfectly in the bathroom or hallway as a subtle decor, while still exuding that peaceful vibe I like." —Vivien Lee, Affiliate Fashion Writer

"I'm prone to being cold all the time. Blame it on my blood circulation; I really don't know. That's why I think it's time to pick up a rug for my desk. The coldest part of me is my feet, and even though I wear fuzzy socks around the house, it doesn't help that my desk is near the window. The soft fluffy faux sheepskin rug not only looks elegant, but it sounds so cozy for the colder months ahead. I also appreciate how they offer the rug in different shapes, sizes, and colors." —Vivien Lee, Affiliate Fashion Writer

"Toaster ovens always confused me growing up, but my roommate brought one when we moved in together, and I saw the light and am never going back. I love how I can easily heat up dinner without the whole production of preheating an oven or evenly toast bread that doesn’t fit entirely in a conventional toaster...and there’s a broil function! Toaster ovens are magical." —Rebecca Sax, Affiliate Coordinator

"Ambient lighting is top of mind because it's been popping off on TikTok. The sleek, minimal design of these makes them ideal for lots of different design styles. You also get two for less than $60, and I love a deal!" —Chinazor Offor, Affiliate Associate Writer

"As everyone should know by now, I'm the Shopping team's resident coffee snob. I love my morning pour-over and my afternoon cold brew, but I've been ready to step up my espresso game for a while. Although a high price tag, I've been eyeing this espresso machine by Breville because it has great reviews, would look lovely on my kitchen counter, and is currently 40% off on Wayfair!" —Kate Spencer, Affiliate Strategist

"I live in a studio apartment without a closet (I know!), so I'm always looking for storage solutions that don't take up much space. I have a tiny sliver of an opening between the end of my kitchen cabinet and the wall and this will slide in perfectly! Can’t wait to hide all of my spices and miscellaneous cooking accessories in here." —Kate Spencer, Affiliate Strategist

"This is technically a kids’ rug but as someone who loves outer space, I absolutely need this in my living room." —Jinnie Lee, Freelance Affiliate Writer

"I'm always excited to find good, ultra-soft sheets! You could never have too many sheets in my book. Not too cooling and not too warm, it's the perfectly balanced sheets my bed's been begging for." —Mercedes Viera, Associate Deals Writer

"I’m no gamer, but there’s something about the aesthetic and comfortable back support that just gets me. Plus, according to its reviews, it’s super easy to assemble which is essential for me." —Mercedes Viera, Associate Deals Writer

"My current apartment already came with a desk, and I know I’m definitely getting a height-adjustable desk when I move out. As someone who has a hard time stepping away from their work, this adjustable desk would be perfect for me and my pained back. " —Mercedes Viera, Associate Deals Writer

"Okay, so rugs can be really expensive – like half your rent expensive — and if you’re like me, you’re not in that tax bracket. This cream-colored zig-zag pattern rug is perfect for my apartment since it’s not too visually loud, but still adds plenty of cozy texture. Plus, it’s easy to clean and super soft under bare feet." —Karina Hoshikawa, Beauty & Wellness Market Writer

"I’ve owned this ladder bookshelf for over a year now, and it’s still one of my favorite home purchases to date. For starters, it was *so* easy to put together — and I basically break out in hives at the thought of assembling furniture. Secondly, it was super affordable yet is a legit stylish piece of storage. It’s the perfect place to display trinkets, books, beauty products, and so much more. (I even keep a basket of dog toys at the bottom.) Best of all, it’s a true must-have for anyone working with a small space since it takes up relatively little floor room." —Karina Hoshikawa, Beauty & Wellness Market Writer

"When I moved into my new apartment last year, one of my favorite aspects of my new space was the seated counter space in the kitchen. I did a double-take when I saw these highly-rated faux-leather bar stools; they look way more expensive than they are! I love that they add some warmth to the space but are still simple enough to not clash with any of my other furniture." —Karina Hoshikawa, Beauty & Wellness Market Writer

"I needed a couch — a cheap couch that didn't look like its price tag and didn't feel like a wooden table when you sat on it. So, I took a risk on this seat and fell in love with it (see what I did there?). Assembly is a breeze and only requires you to screw on the four peg legs which, by the way, are super sturdy. You can actually sink into the cushion which is perfect and the loveseat as a whole looks great in my one-bedroom apartment. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking to save space AND money." —Alexandra Polk, Lifestyle Writer

"It's the year 2022, aka, if you want something in cow print I guarantee that you can get it with just a few quick google searches. I saw this dairy-inspired chair during my weekly Wayfair peruse and knew that it belonged in my apartment. To my surprise, you don't only pay for its look, you also get a cushy chair with a posture-correcting back and smooth wheels. The gold accents are the cherry on top and everyone should know that this furniture cutie exists!" —Alexandra Polk, Lifestyle Writer

"There is an alternate universe where I have enough counter space in my apartment to place this beautiful contraption atop it. I mean, think of this machine accompanying movie nights with friends; my late-night Demon Slayer binges; and those days when I require some fresh movie theatre popcorn to stabilize my mood. For some reason, you can buy this popcorn maker from Wayfair, and for some reason, I already feel emotionally attached to it." —Alexandra Polk, Lifestyle Writer