Time to get real: Hershey's Kisses-filled candy canes, Russell Stover teddy bears, and other drugstore-bought offerings do not qualify as holiday gifts — even for a Secret Santa exchange. The good news? There are scores of far more treasure-worthy goodies that are just as affordable and convenient as any drugstore score. In fact, 12 of them are just a click away. Here, we've gathered our favorite under-$25 picks perfect for every gift-swap participant, from the makeup addict to the serial-selfie-taker (click through and you'll get it, promise). Happy Santa-ing!

More from Entertaining

Unbothered

What Netflix’s Black Superhero Drama Supacell Gets R...

Minor spoilers ahead. Over the past few years, Black British TV has become renowned for its bold storytelling and nuanced portrayal of Black British lives,

by Liv Facey

Friendship

Adult Sleepovers Are Giving Us What Big Nights Out Can’t

Heidi Currid, from Manchester, UK, has a sleepover with her friends at least once a month. And no, she’s not 13, she’s 30. “We meet up at one of our

by Tanyel Mustafa

Latinx

Drag Performer Xitlali Celesté Couldn’t Have a Quinceanera....

A spiritual and social event, quinceañeras are a traditional coming-of-age celebration for Latina youth. When a girl turns 15, she throws on a big poofy g

by R29 Somos

Dedicated Feature

Throwing A Party Is Good For You — Here’s Why

There are exactly two types of people: those who recoil at the thought of hosting a party, and those who absolutely thrive on it. For folks who fall into t

by Jenna Igneri

Unbothered

7 Tips For Hosting Your Very First Grown-Up Friendsgiving Dinner

The holiday season has crept up on us, and I am not prepared at all! Thanksgiving has always been my favorite holiday, and growing up, my house was the go

by Sandy Pierre

Shopping

13 Ways To Get Into Your Speak Now (Taylor’s Version)

Drop everything and meet us in the pouring rain. We’ve entered the Speak Now (Taylor’s Version) era aka the biggest moment of the year for the most ann

by Esther Newman

Gift Guides
12 Super-Unique Gifts At Uncommon Goods (& They’re All Unde...
You’re reading an On-Site Shopping story — meaning you can browse, add to cart, and actually purchase the product recommendations featured below withou
by Jinnie Lee

Dedicated Feature
How 9 Families Are Keeping Game Night Alive In 2021
No matter your family traditions, it’s safe to say they’ve evolved throughout the years — including (but not limited to) the occasional game night. A
by Melissa Kravitz

Gifts For Mom
R29’s Extra Gifted Mother’s Day Gift Guide
YOUR MOM MOM-IN-LAW GRAND MOM LIKE A MOM PET MOM From last-minute blooms to surprise bottles of wine and the good EVOO, we’ve got your Mom’s Day crowdp
by Marissa Rosenblum

Hype Machine
Gaming Chairs Are The Unsung Champions Of WFH Support
by Cortne Bonilla

Party In
How To Celebrate The End Of The Strangest Year Ever
One interesting part of living in the age of social media is that we’ve all experienced the sensation of finding out that one of our most strongly held o
by Cait Munro

Gift Guides
14 Pleasing Puzzle Gifts To Pass The Time Your Giftee Would Have ...
by Avery Felman

12 Secret Santa Gifts That Put Drugstore Buys To Shame

12 Secret Santa Gifts That Put Drugstore Buys To Shame

More from Entertaining